My response to Ben Bateman has received some kind and generous praise for which I am grateful. It also led to some replies at MarriageDebate.com from Mary Catelli and Ben Bateman. Let's start with Ms. Catelli's response. In reference to my use of the word "parent" for one with the legal and/or moral responsibility to raise and care for a child, she writes:
Except that he is not using the word "parent" to denote someone with responsibilities toward a child. He means, by it, a genetic or adoptive parent or someone who is having sexual intercourse with a genetic or adoptive parent. Your roommate might help raise your child without being your lover. So might your neighbor or -- especially -- your nanny. Should all of these people get married? Why are these people not "parents" in his parlance?
Actually, I did use the word "parent" to denote someone with responsibilities toward a child. I do not mean someone who is having sexual intercourse with a genetic or adoptive parent. I have no idea what gave Ms. Catelli this idea. Perhaps she does not realize that in many same-sex couples both spouses have the same legal (and moral) responsibility to the child. For example Hillary and Julie Goodridge are both the legal parents of their lovely daughter Annie. For a quick overview of second parent adoptions see this page from the National Center for Lesbian Rights. I used the word "moral" in addition to "legal" for two reasons. One is to emphasize my belief that is not only the law that creates responsibilities, but we have ethical obligations as well. The second is that there are a few states where second parent adoptions are not allowed. In this case, if the couple has jointly committed to raising a child together with equal responsibilities, I still recognize those obligations even if the law does not. In a similar manner I see many same-sex couples taking on the same ethical obligations to care for each other, only the law refusing to recognize this. In these cases I will refer to them as spouses even if the law does not.
In any case, I am not referring to somebody helping to raise somebody else's child. That was a phrase used by Ben Bateman to refer to all non-genetic parents. So I generally make no pronouncement on whether a person should marry his or her nanny or roommate. As to why roommates and nannies are not "parents" in my parlance, they do not have the same legal responsiblities to care and raise for the child. And it is not simply a matter of them taking on the same responsiblities, but the law refusing to recognize it. A roommate is doing a favor for a friend. A nanny is hired for her services. The differences are enormous, but perhaps the most significant is that either can walk away at will. A parent cannot (legally and/or ethically) just walk away from a child.
UPDATE: Elizabeth Marquardt also seems to think that I'm defining parent as somebody who has sex with your parent. Was it something I said, or do people just assume that this is all a same-sex spouse is. We are talking about legal parents here. These are couples who decided jointly to raise a child, generally after making a commitment to one another. Elizabeth herself refers to the distinction between this and a stepparent who she writes
entered the family primarily out of love and interest in [her] biological parent, not because they were taking up any grand moral obligation towards [her]. And really, how many people look at a snot-nosed ten year old they have no relation to and say to themselves, "gee, I want to commit myself to this kid forever?"
That's why I don't give much weight to the comparison to stepparents. Elizabeth goes on to point out that some same-sex couples will marry after a previous union bringing in stepchildren, just as occurs with some opposite-sex marriages. Some same-sex marriages will end in divorce. I agree. This does not mean, that marriage can't help to create a more stable home, or that divorce proceedings don't offer more protection to the child than the dissolution of a cohabiting couple. We don't argue that parents shouldn't marry because it might end in divorce. I know Elizabeth works to highlight the benefits of marriage, and strives to prevent divorce. I believe same-sex couples and their families are worthy of this same effort on their behalf.
(Part 2 is here)
, Viagra, vvctnr, Discount viagra online, zlyjk, Cialis online, 82747, Levitra online, lizttg, Viagra online pharmacy, :-D, Generic viagra, :((, Viagra, cwlgmr, Viagra sales, =), Viagra, 024,
Posted by: Cialis vs viagra | December 13, 2011 at 03:25 AM
, Levitra online without prescription, 8629, Viagra, vrkc, Buy viagra, >:P, Buy viagra online, :-PP, Viagra vs cialis, 5542, Viagra online, pgaufn, Cialis online without prescription, :-P, Online viagra, =D, Generic viagra, 4092,
Posted by: Cheap cialis online | December 13, 2011 at 03:49 AM
, Discount viagra, :)), Cheap viagra online, 840, Generic viagra, 873, Viagra, ewqyhi, Cialis generic, 7010, Cheap viagra, jdrc, Does generic viagra work, 53730, Cheap viagra, 8-P, Online viagra, 20862,
Posted by: Generic viagra | December 13, 2011 at 04:20 AM
, Cheap viagra online, 421100, Cheap viagra 100mg, kcua, Does generic viagra work, 8P, Viagra, kiw, Cialis online without prescription, %-DD, Viagra online, 6635, Generic viagra, >:]]], Viagra, 03322, Cialis vs viagra, 857,
Posted by: Generic viagra | December 16, 2011 at 03:24 AM
, Generic viagra online, >:-), Viagra online without prescription, 09356, Cialis online, spmu, Levitra online, 106, Viagra, ccjwol, Order viagra, :P, Viagra, :-(((, Cheap viagra online, 348469, Cheap viagra, kzmul,
Posted by: Viagra | December 22, 2011 at 03:52 AM
, Cheap viagra online, xpk, Cheapest viagra, =-), Generic viagra, 618, Viagra online, kupd, Cheap cialis, 455322, Viagra, tgvbk, Cheap viagra, 416, Generic viagra, :-)), Viagra, qncj,
Posted by: Viagra for sale | December 22, 2011 at 04:03 AM
, Generic levitra, >:]]], Generic viagra online, 538789, Viagra, =OO, Viagra online without prescription, 12295, Viagra for sale, hvavpb, Viagra, >:), Cheap cialis, 8-], Viagra, 564483, Viagra, qvlyg,
Posted by: Viagra online | December 22, 2011 at 04:20 AM
, Viagra, gttui, Sildenafil, 8]], Viagra sales, 3792, Viagra, xxuf, Viagra, =)), Cheap viagra online, fnfsdi, Viagra, 0464, Viagra vs levitra, 8OO, Cialis vs viagra, >:[[,
Posted by: Generic viagra online | December 23, 2011 at 03:18 AM
, Cheap viagra online, 44402, Cheap viagra, >:PP, Generic viagra prices, 228723, Viagra online canadian pharmacy, 8), Cialis vs viagra, :DD, Viagra, 8-O, Generic viagra, >:-], Viagra, 8(, Viagra online, 8-))),
Posted by: Cheap viagra | December 23, 2011 at 04:01 AM
, Levitra, 8OOO, Viagra online pharmacy, %-]], Generic viagra, :-[[[, Cheap viagra, >:)), Viagra online, pxjny, Generic cialis, %]], Viagra, flvfe, Viagra online, >:), Viagra online, 39253,
Posted by: Levitra cialis viagra | December 23, 2011 at 04:21 AM
, Viagra online without prescription, 178236, Viagra generic, 823, Viagra, qmgdo, Viagra online, :[, Viagra, 068, Buy viagra online, 717702, Generic viagra online, lxx, Levitra, zdh, Generic cialis, =],
Posted by: Cheap viagra online | December 23, 2011 at 04:21 AM
, Viagra for sale, 8PP, Generic viagra online, :))), Viagra online, 90220, Discount viagra, vmtni, Cheap viagra, lebxpe, Discount viagra, 438, Viagra online without prescription, >:P, Levitra, gzd, Cialis, hdbzh,
Posted by: Viagra side effects | December 24, 2011 at 03:06 AM
, Viagra online, 726, Generic viagra online, 36252, Cialis online, =-PP, Generic levitra online, :P, Generic viagra, jze, Buy viagra online, 887, Generic viagra online, %-DDD, Viagra online, 6612, Viagra, ngc,
Posted by: Viagra | December 25, 2011 at 03:11 AM
, Viagra online without prescription, yyd, Generic viagra prices, 706492, Discount viagra online, pxc, Viagra for sale, 57182, Viagra online without a prescription, 721851, Viagra online, 5738, Discount viagra, >:O, Cialis, 48880, Cialis, eenlkm,
Posted by: Cialis vs viagra | December 25, 2011 at 03:25 AM
, Levitra, rvcjbr, Viagra online, =], Viagra price, =OOO, Buy viagra, 60105, Viagra vs cialis, >:))), Cheap viagra, %-), Cialis, 900484, Viagra, kng, Viagra, %[[,
Posted by: Buy viagra online | December 25, 2011 at 03:42 AM
, Viagra online, xswaf, Viagra, :D, Cialis online, =(, Levitra generic, =], Viagra, gynb, Cheap viagra, >:OO, Generic viagra, 386530, Viagra, 240829, Cheap viagra, 670,
Posted by: Viagra | December 25, 2011 at 04:12 AM
, Viagra online, :-DDD, Discount viagra online, >:[[[, Cialis, kixfb, Generic levitra online, jlis, Viagra online pharmacy, 2622, Viagra price, niu, Viagra generic fast, 9681, Viagra, 293, Viagra, 922,
Posted by: Viagra | December 26, 2011 at 03:16 AM
, Levitra, wlnzm, Viagra online, 31980, Viagra, 707, Viagra, =-], Sildenafil, 422, Viagra, 979635, Cialis online, gesl, Viagra, nmamj, Viagra, callc,
Posted by: Cheap cialis | December 26, 2011 at 03:41 AM
, Discount viagra, 6935, Viagra cheap, pqktc, Generic viagra, 8[, Viagra online, :P, Cialis, 585121, Viagra, 1532, Sildenafil, >:DDD, Viagra, 033, Viagra online, 306,
Posted by: Viagra online canadian pharmacy | December 26, 2011 at 03:42 AM
BVm0zG pprovqpbhhxm, [url=http://fjrxarwgiedh.com/]fjrxarwgiedh[/url], [link=http://gaxeqysbowfh.com/]gaxeqysbowfh[/link], http://vefhixytwjeg.com/
Posted by: igeyxsnfeq | December 26, 2011 at 04:01 AM
, Viagra, 08793, Generic viagra, jxhn, Generic viagra online, %-))), Cheap viagra online, zpaps, Viagra online without a prescription, 005, Viagra online, dlp, Online viagra, pvuv, Levitra, 277, Cialis online, >:[,
Posted by: Cialis | December 26, 2011 at 04:04 AM
, Generic viagra online, 0526, Cheap viagra online, jozi, Order cialis, eqtaa, Levitra online, 584, Viagra, vtxvco, Viagra price, icjj, Viagra, 5334, Viagra, ylhprc, Cheap viagra, 8-PPP,
Posted by: Viagra vs cialis | December 26, 2011 at 04:21 AM
, Viagra sales, =-))), Cialis vs viagra, cycqum, Cialis vs viagra, abc, Discount viagra, >:-]]], Cheap viagra, 1017, Cheap viagra, 82240, Viagra generic fast, 1685, Viagra, jin, Viagra, erxr,
Posted by: Generic cialis | December 27, 2011 at 03:01 AM
, Viagra for sale, bge, Generic viagra, hnojmi, Viagra, %-O, Discount viagra, 8-]]], Buy generic viagra, =-], Viagra online, 592, Viagra, 91147, Levitra viagra cialis, kwurq, Cialis online, 561882,
Posted by: Viagra online | December 27, 2011 at 03:21 AM
, Viagra online, 76569, Viagra online, 947, Cialis vs viagra, oamio, Discount viagra, 4879, Generic viagra online, 85949, Viagra, vygo, Viagra price, wyj, Viagra online, uinpo, Viagra, hcqh,
Posted by: Viagra | December 27, 2011 at 04:02 AM